I have been building Battle of the Atlantic games all year — taking different roles such as the escort commander, the analyst in the Citadel, the plotting game with a paper chart (more on this to come soon….). All of them from the Allied side.
FALSE COLOURS is the first from the other end of the telescope: you are the German raider, the thing everyone else is looking for. I thought it would be a change of costume. It turned out to be a different kind of game, and it took me four attempts to find out what kind.
The history first, because the history is the design. In 1940 Germany had no fleet to fight the Royal Navy for the sea lanes, so it did what it had done in 1914: converted fast freighters into warships and sent them to the far oceans wearing other nations’ flags. Atlantis, the most successful, stayed out for 622 days as a Soviet ship, a Japanese ship, a Dutch ship, two British ships. She carried six 15 cm guns behind hinged plates, a seaplane, 350 men, and a paint locker. Her real weapon was that nobody knew what she looked like. Every ship she stopped was a chance for a wireless operator to get three letters away — QQQ, disguised raider — with a position and a description, and once the Admiralty had a good description the cruisers stopped patrolling and started hunting. She died at a U-boat rendezvous that Bletchley Park had read.
So the game has no health bar. It has anonymity, and you never see it. You see its symptoms.
Version one was a text game: sighting, identification, approach, the moment, aftermath, each a paragraph and three buttons. It was historically careful and I was pleased with it, and my playtester — a patient man — said it was “a little samey”. I added more ship types. Samey. I added temperaments for the masters, one-off incidents from the real cruises, events between ships, a cruise-long story. Still samey. Three passes, three identical verdicts. The one thing he said made his pulse go up was a small real-time sequence I had bolted on to the wireless-room decision: a bar for her operator, a bar for your salvo, a few seconds to decide.
That was the whole lesson, and I had been adding content around it for a fortnight without seeing it. He wasn’t experiencing the variety as play. He was experiencing it as reading. The words changed; the shape of each encounter did not. Twelve times you read a paragraph and tapped one of three buttons. The wireless room was the only part that wasn’t reading — and it was the only part that worked.
So I rebuilt the encounter as one continuous live scene. The recognition plate sharpens as the range closes on a real clock and you call her type — Freighter, Tanker, Liner, Warship — before she calls yours. Her suspicion climbs every tenth of a second, driven by your speed, your course, the light, and how believable your current name is in this ocean. The lamp interrupts with WHAT SHIP and a six-second countdown. Hold parallel and the gunnery officer puts the glasses on her, and sometimes what he sees is boats stowed inboard and something square on the after deck, which is not a liner. You drop the flaps when you choose. Then the wireless room, now with a rangefinder needle you have to catch in the band. The diary lines went from paragraphs to sentences.
The next report said the game “went much better and was much more interesting”, and every pass since has been building the world around a loop that finally works: a chart with three oceans and false names that carry differently in each, six captains with signatures, supply ships that become traps once the enemy is reading the mail, the war arriving by wireless on the real dates, a stoker with a burst appendix at two in the morning, and a cruise that lasts as long as the oil does.
Three things I will keep from this. First: when a playtester says “samey” three times, stop adding and start subtracting — the problem is the shape, not the content. Second: the part of your game that makes someone’s pulse go up is telling you what the whole game should be. Listen to it before you listen to your design document. Third, and this is the uncomfortable one: I would not have found any of this without an honest tester who was willing to say “this is not exciting enough” to a build I was proud of. Find that person. Do what they say.
FALSE COLOURS is on itch now, pay what you want, one file, plays on a phone. Take Atlantis first. Then tell me how long you lasted.